Is This 2018 Again?

If you lived through Q4 2018, this week felt familiar. Fear peaked on Christmas Eve. I remember it well.

This is not a transcript, but calls went like this:

Client: "Adam! Why are we down so much today?"

Adam: "I know! Everybody is wondering... It has to do with a low-probability interaction of automated selling, a fear dynamic and the Fed. Do you have a coffee or a drink? Let me dig in and explain."

There are some themes today that fit the 2018 analogy closely:

  1. Broken charts

  2. Selling nobody could fully explain

  3. A hawkish Fed

Tech has taken the hit, with the Nasdaq 100 already about 70% of the way to its 2018 drop. But the canary in the coal mine, credit, which is usually the first to smell real trouble, has moved only 15% as much as it did in the 2018 drop.[1]

It is important to keep perspective. Yes, stocks are rattled. The economy isn't. Earnings appear healthy!

So what does this mean? Much of the selloff is a market behavior we call "systematic supply."

Systematic supply is selling by rules-based funds that trade on price and volatility, not on company fundamentals. When markets fall, their models force them to sell, and the selling feeds on itself until it's done.[2]

Illustration 1. Estimated systematic selling around the November 19 Nasdaq 100 rout. Source: Bloomberg, citing JPMorgan and Barclays estimates.[2]

My own Bloomberg work identifies 25 times since 1990 when stocks were this expensive and fear (the VIX) spiked like it did today.[3]

When the Fed raised rates, it affected stock values the next year negatively.

When there is a market shock, and the Fed reacts to that shock by changing their policy stance, while earnings held up, the next year stock values rose 22% to 38%.[3]

The simple fact is that earnings are still growing and given the move in the Fed Funds futures market today, the December 9th Fed meeting could tip the odds our way.

The people who sold on Christmas Eve 2018 watched a rally from the sidelines. Don't let the "systematic supply" bot make that call for you. Play the long game.

Past performance is not indicative of future results. This is for informational purposes only and is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.

Sources and References

  1. Goldman Sachs Global Banking & Markets, FICC & Equities (Brian Garrett), "2026 vs 2018 ... pre-weekend prep," November 20, 2026, pp. 1-2. Trading desk commentary, not Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research.

  2. Natalia Kniazhevich, "Fast-Money Systematic Funds Stoked $2.3 Trillion Tech-Stock Rout," Bloomberg News, November 20, 2026. View source PDF

  3. Dogpatch Wealth analysis of Bloomberg data: 12-month S&P 500 returns after the VIX topped 30 at 18-22x forward P/E, 25 episodes since 1990, grouped by Fed policy regime.

Adam Gould

Adam Gould is the Founder and Wealth Advisor at Dogpatch Wealth in San Francisco. He has twenty years experience in wealth management and launched his independent practice in 2014.

https://dogpatchwealth.com
Next
Next

The Gold Rush Gets a Ticker